Being Human

I am a human being, and I am woman. But there have been times in my life when I’ve been treated like the latter instead of, rather than in addition to, the former.

Why was I thinking about this today? Probably because I read a blog post by Amanda Palmer on her wedding to Neil Gaiman, which was in the house of the writer Ayelet Waldman. So I started thinking about strong, creative women like Palmer and Waldman who do their own work, go their own way. And I wondered why it’s been difficult for me to do that at certain points in my life. I think it’s partly a result of growing up in the South, where there were certain things women weren’t expected to do. Create their own companies, for instance. Write best-selling novels. They were expected to support their families. To be nice, to avoid controversy.

It was a surprise, coming North for law school, to find that I was being treated differently – that I was expected to be as competitive as my male classmates. That no one cared whether I was nice or not. And you know what? It was liberating.

I’ll tell you two stories to illustrate what I mean. While I was in law school, I spent the summers working at law firms in Richmond, Virginia. In the South again. In those law firms, when we went to lunch, the men always let the women get into the elevator first. So, of course, all the women were at the back of the elevator. And then, when any women needed to get out, all the men would get out first, stand in the hallway until they got out, and then get back into the elevator. It was an elaborate and inconvenient ritual. And while it was meant to be courteous, it was also insulting, because it was a daily marker of difference: you might be an associate at a law firm, but you were still a woman. You were never just another human being.

The second is more personal. After I ended a relationship, the man I’d been in a relationship with decided that he could no longer speak with me, that it was too painful. And then he asked his best friend, who was also a friend of mine, not to speak with me either. And because of their relationship, his friend agreed. I thought for a long time about why that incident was so painful, and finally decided that it was because I had been treated, not as a human being, but as a woman. (Of course what I thought at the time was, are we in fifth grade? I was incredulous.) As a human being, I had a right to form friendships of my own. But as a woman, I was the one he had been in a relationship with, and that meant he had the right to ask male friends to end their own friendships with me. Yes, this too happened in the South.

It took me a long time to get past the lessons I learned, growing up in the South. To realize that I could be ambitious, could create the life I wanted for myself without asking anyone’s permission. That I could speak my mind, generate controversy. That, as the historian Laurel Thatcher Ulrich wrote, “well-behaved women seldom make history.” And that I had a right to want to make history, do something important. Change the world.

That, in fact, the world needed changing, and it was much more important for me to try to change it than be nice.

No wonder being treated as a human being, rather than a woman, felt liberating. (Although it was also, initially, disconcerting. I was not used to competing, to being in an environment where niceness got you exactly nowhere. Believe me, it counts for nothing at Harvard Law.) But I am inescapably both.

Women like Palmer and Waldman generate controversy. They make us talk about what it means to be a woman, and what it means to be a human being, and how to negotiate those two identities. And that is in part what I value about them and their work. I hope my own work participates, in some way, in that discussion.

I’m starting the year more tired than I would like to be. Here she is, tired Dora (if you look closely, you can see the lines under my eyes):

So I have a lot of work to do, simply on myself. Rest, become healthier. But I also want to work on all the projects I have planned. I’ll tell you about them as the year progresses. I think it’s going to be a particularly interesting one.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Being Human

  1. This made me think, and, I also enjoyed it. (That is not always the case) There are some profound observations on our roles in society, and how they can hamper, or provoke a person. I use provoke, not in the negative context, but in the context of motivation. I hope you get the rest you seek and your year is indeed an interesting one.

  2. Stina Leicht says:

    I enjoyed reading this. Thanks for posting it. Your words verify my own experience, growing up female in Texas. I was born in St. Louis and then moved South when I was eight. I like to think I remember enough of life outside of the South and that it helped me through the rough spots, but I’m not entirely sure. Ultimately, I found the punk and goth scenes, and that’s when I found my voice. That’s when I began to dare. So, I say hurray for Amanda Palmer. She’s a great example for the rest of us.

  3. When I was at Andover, I found that I had to be better than the male students to achieve the same recognition… After having been raised (in Carmel, CA) as very elegant arm candy, this was a Mighty Yelp and acknowledgement that my soul had value and meaning and that I didn’t need to just be pretty, charming, and well-dressed.

    Of course, my trouble was that I have always wanted to be both. To look “stunning,” “classy,” and “lovely,” and then to slash the sails with my words and thoughts, take off my heels and run through the wet grass.

    Being a bridge is never straightforward. You are asked to fly while remaining connected to two immovable places.

    You, Dora, will construct a beautiful, elegant bridge. I look forward to seeing its drawings and construction.

  4. Being Human is an important title, but I did not expect a comparison of being human and and being woman.
    I think Being Human requires at least a willingness to look at the same standard. Giving equal rights to all human beings, regardless of any gender, any race, and any specific character.
    Easy in theory with words. Not so easy in daily practice, in today’s world.

  5. I liked this post. I also feel as if sometimes men view women as alien, or not-quite-human. This de-humanization is in the language of our culture. I’ve lived in the Northeast, in California, in the Midwest, and in the South (all U.S.), and the expectations of women are a little bit different in every place, but there’s never true equality.

    In the video game industry, you’ll see a lot of young men at the office, and maybe 1 or 2 women. It’s not that these studios have an active discrimination policy (I’m sure they don’t), but it’s a combination of “boy’s club” mentality mixed with the common expectation that women should go into practical careers, not something fun.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s